The Most Important Thing: Uncommon Sense for the Thoughtful Investor

Marks, Howard


TABLE OF CONTENT

  • Dedication
  • About the Annotators
  • Foreword by Bruce C. Greenwald
  • Introduction
  • 1 The Most Important Thing is … Second Level Thinking
  • 2 … Understanding Market Efficiency (and Its Limitations)
  • 3 … Value
  • 4 … The Relationship Between Price and Value
  • 5 … Understanding Risk
  • 6 … Recognizing Risk
  • 7 … Controlling Risk
  • 8 … Being Attentive to Cycles
  • 9 … Awareness of the Pendulum
  • 10 … Combating Negative Influences
  • 11 … Contrarianism
  • 12 … Finding Bargains
  • 13 … Patient Opportunism
  • 14 … Knowing What you Don’t Know
  • 15 … Having a Sense for Where We Stand
  • 16 … Appreciating the Role of Luck
  • 17 … Investing Defensively
  • 18 … Avoiding pitfalls
  • 19 … Adding Value
  • 20 … Reasonable Expectations
  • 21 … Pulling It All Together
  • About the Author

About the Annotators

  • Christopher C. Davis – a portfolio manager of the Davis Large Cap Value portfolios; M.A. from the University of St. Andrews in Scotland.
  • Joel Greenblatt – Columbia Business School; a managing partner of Gotham Capital
    The Big Secret for the Small Investor (Crown Business, 2011),
    The Little Book That Beats the Market (John Wiley & Sons, 2005)
    You Can Be A Stock Market Genius (Simon & Schuster, 1997).
  • Bruce C. Greenwald – Columbia Business School;
    A Radically Simplified Approach to Business Strategy (with Judd Kahn, Putnam Penguin, 2005),
    Value Investing: From Graham to Buffett and Beyond (with Judd Kahn, et al, Wiley, 2001).
  • Paul Johnson – Columbia University; founded Nicusa Capital
  • Seth A. Klarman – the president of The Baupost Group;
    Margin of Safety (HarperCollins, 1991),

    lead editor for Security Analysis: Sixth Edition (McGraw-Hill, 2008)

    • innate: inborn; natural: superior investement ability seems to be innate.
      • resonates: 共鸣: these four thinkers discuss how Marks’s philosophy sesonates with, refines, or occasionally deffers from their own.
      • surrogate: 代理:I like to think of The Most Important Thing Illuminated as a surrogate book group with five of the best investment thinkers alive.

INRODUCTION

  • creed, a system of religious belief; a faith: I consider it my creed, and in course of my investing career it has served like a religion.
  • ensnare, catch in or as in a trap: avoid the pitfalls that ensnare so many.
  • disservice, a harmful action: Those who try to simplify investing do their audience a great disservice.

Heaven for me would be seven little words: “I never thought of it that way.”

  • tick, √: When potential clients want to understand what makes Oaktree tick, their number one question is usually some variation on “What have been the keys to your success?”

A philosophy has to be the sum of many ideas accumulated over a long period of time from a variety of sources. One cannot develop an effective philosophy without having been exposed to life’s lessons.

It’s not the specific facts or processes I learned that mattered most, but being exposed to the two main schools of investment thought and having to ponder how to reconcile and synthesize them into my own approach.

Importantly, a philosophy like mine comes from going through life with your eyes open. You must be aware of what’s taking place in the world and of what results those events lead to. Only in this way can you put the lessons to work when similar circumstances materialize again.

Seth klarman: Keeping your eyes open also increases the probability that you will be prepared for something that has never before occurred. … Alertness can help to identify and possibly avoid growing risks before it is too late. Marks makes this point in chapter 5.

I like to say, “Experience is what you got when you didn’t get what you wanted.”

Good times teach only bad lessons: that investing is easy, that you know its secrets, and that you needn’t worry about risk. The most valuable lessons are learned in tough times. In that sense, I’ve been “fortunate” to have lived through some doozies: the Arab oil embargo, stagflation, Nifty Fifty stock collapse and “death of equities” of the 1970s; Black Monday in 1987, when the Dow Jones Industrial Index lost 22.6 percent of its value in one day; the 1994 spike in interest rates that put rate-sensitive debt instruments into freefall; the emerging market crisis, Russian default and meltdown of Long-Term Capital Management in 1998; the bursting of the tech-stock bubble in 2000–2001; the accounting scandals of 2001–2002; and the worldwide financial crisis of 2007–2008.

If you read widely, you can learn from people whose ideas merit publishing. Some of the most important for me were Charley Ellis’s great article “The Loser’s Game” (The Financial Analysts Journal, July-August 1975), A Short History of Financial Euphoria, by John Kenneth Galbraith (New York: Viking, 1990) and Nassim Nicholas Taleb’s Fooled by Randomness (New York: Texere, 2001).

Finally, I’ve been extremely fortunate to learn directly from some outstanding thinkers: John Kenneth Galbraith on human foibles; Warren Buffett on patience and contrarianism; Charlie Munger on the importance of reasonable expectations; Bruce Newberg on “probability and outcome”; Michael Milken on conscious risk bearing; and Ric Kayne on setting “traps” ( underrated investment opportunities where you can make a lot but can’t lose a lot). I’ve also benefited from my association with Peter Bernstein, Seth Klarman, Jack Bogle, Jacob Rothschild, Jeremy Grantham, Joel Greenblatt, Tony Pace, Orin Kramer, Jim Grant and Doug Kass.

I’m convinced that no idea can be any better than the action taken on it, and that’s especially true in the world of investing.

3 … Value

For investing to be reliably successful, an accurate estimate of intrinsic value is the indispensable starting point.

Warren Buffett says that the best investment course would teach just two things well: How to value an investment and how to think about market price movements.

Herb Stein’s wry observation that “if something cannot go on forever, it will stop.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 21 · Location 510
cerebral
Highlight(yellow) – Page 21 · Location 521
ephemeral
Highlight(yellow) – Page 23 · Location 550
“good” businesses that are available at an attractive price.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 25 · Location 581
offing,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 25 · Location 582
batting
Highlight(yellow) – Page 25 · Location 585
consistency trumps drama.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 25 · Location 591
It’s hard to consistently do the right thing as an investor. But it’s impossible to consistently do the right thing at the right time. The most we value investors can hope for is to be right about an asset’s value and buy when it’s available for less.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 26 · Location 603
“buying dollars for fifty cents.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 26 · Location 606
“Being too far ahead of your time is indistinguishable from being wrong.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 27 · Location 617
many people tend to fall further in love with the thing they’ve bought as its price rises, since they feel validated, and they like it less as the price falls, when they begin to doubt their decision to buy. This makes it very difficult to hold, and to buy more at lower prices
Highlight(yellow) – Page 27 · Location 619
If you liked it at 60, you should like it more at 50 . . . and much more at 40 and 30.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 28 · Location 633
serum,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 29 · Location 642
“buying good things,”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 29 · Location 642
“buying things well.”
Highlight(pink) – Page 29 · Location 650
obsolescence,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 32 · Location 699
exerts
Highlight(orange) – Page 32 · Location 701
manifestations.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 33 · Location 709
The key is who likes the investment now and who doesn’t.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 33 · Location 715
perilous.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 33 · Location 715
The biggest losers—be they Nifty-Fifty stocks in 1969, Internet stocks in 1999, or mortgage vehicles in 2006—had
Highlight(yellow) – Page 33 · Location 717
“priced for perfection,” “on the pedestal of popularity,” and “nothing can go wrong.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 33 · Location 722
–RANDOM THOUGHTS ON THE IDENTIFICATION OF INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES, January 24, 1994
Highlight(yellow) – Page 34 · Location 725
elusive.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 34 · Location 737
nugget
Highlight(yellow) – Page 35 · Location 741
rendition
Highlight(yellow) – Page 36 · Location 764
infatuation
Highlight(yellow) – Page 37 · Location 784
serendipity;
Highlight(yellow) – Page 38 · Location 791
John Maynard Keynes pointed out, “The market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent.” Howard Marks:
Highlight(yellow) – Page 39 · Location 799
Risk means more things can happen than will happen. –Elroy Dimson
Highlight(yellow) – Page 40 · Location 817
equilibration,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 44 · Location 870
peril.
Highlight(orange) – Page 46 · Location 905
Warren Buffett and Julian Robertson in 1999.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 46 · Location 907
quartile
Highlight(yellow) – Page 46 · Location 915
unorthodox
Highlight(yellow) – Page 47 · Location 928
“pedestal
Highlight(yellow) – Page 47 · Location 930
The most dangerous investment conditions generally stem from psychology that’s too positive.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 47 · Location 934
They believe high return and low risk can be achieved simultaneously by buying things for less than they’re worth. In the same way, overpaying implies both low return and high risk.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 48 · Location 938
the greatest risk in these low-luster bargains lies in the possibility of underperforming in heated bull markets. That’s something the risk-conscious value investor is willing to live with.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 50 · Location 987
congenitally
Highlight(yellow) – Page 51 · Location 998
Elroy Dimson that led off this chapter: “Risk means more things can happen than will happen.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 52 · Location 1018
“There’s a big difference between probability and outcome. Probable things fail to happen—and improbable things happen—all the time.” That’s one of the most important things you can know about investment risk.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 52 · Location 1020
Joel Greenblatt: When thinking about a portfolio of investments, one thing to keep in mind is that the correlation of these improbable occurrences can affect many of your investments at the same time.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 52 · Location 1024
cluster.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 54 · Location 1060
risk cannot be measured. Certainly it cannot be gauged on the basis of what “everybody” says at a moment in time.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 55 · Location 1060
Risk can be judged only by sophisticated, experienced second-level thinkers.
Highlight(pink) – Page 55 · Location 1073
Maybe “worst-case” means “the worst we’ve seen in the past.” But that doesn’t mean things can’t be worse in the future. In 2007, many people’s worst-case assumptions were exceeded.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 57 · Location 1092
because the system is now more stable, we’ll make it less stable through more leverage, more risk taking.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 57 · Location 1093
–Myron Scholes
Highlight(yellow) – Page 57 · Location 1094
it may be more helpful to think of risk as increasing during upswings, as financial imbalances build up, and materializing in recessions. –Andrew Crockett
Highlight(yellow) – Page 57 · Location 1098
Great investing requires both generating returns and controlling risk.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 57 · Location 1099
Risk means uncertainty about which outcome will occur and about the possibility of loss when the unfavorable ones do.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 59 · Location 1124
“Risk is my friend. The more risk I take, the greater my return will be.
Note – Page 59 · Location 1124
high risks demand risk premiums But psychology affects
Highlight(yellow) – Page 59 · Location 1135
There are few things as risky as the widespread belief that there’s no risk,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 60 · Location 1151
The riskiest things : A few times in my career, I’ve seen the rise of a belief that risk has been banished, cycles won’t occur any longer, or the laws of economics have been suspended.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 61 · Location 1154
fairy tales
Highlight(yellow) – Page 61 · Location 1155
adroit
Highlight(yellow) – Page 61 · Location 1161
Pension & Investments
Highlight(yellow) – Page 61 · Location 1166
the degree of risk present in a market derives from the behavior of the participants, not from securities, strategies and institutions. Regardless of what’s designed into market structures, risk will be low only if investors behave prudently.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 62 · Location 1172
The risk-is-gone myth is one of the most dangerous sources of risk, and a major contributor to any bubble.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 62 · Location 1173
intoxicates
Highlight(yellow) – Page 62 · Location 1177
Highlight(yellow) – Page 62 · Location 1177
“Too Much Trust, Too Little Worry.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 62 · Location 1177
carefree, unworried investors are their own worst enemy.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 62 · Location 1179
partook
Highlight(yellow) – Page 62 · Location 1182
Worry and its relatives, distrust, skepticism and risk aversion, are essential ingredients in a safe financial system.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 63 · Location 1192
Investment risk comes primarily from too-high prices, and too-high prices often come from excessive optimism and inadequate skepticism and risk aversion.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 66 · Location 1243
ephemeral
Highlight(yellow) – Page 67 · Location 1255
slender.
Highlight(blue) – Page 67 · Location 1256
reticence.
Highlight(blue) – Page 67 · Location 1265
halcyon
Highlight(yellow) – Page 67 · Location 1266
“It’s only when the tide goes out that you find out who’s been swimming naked.” Pollyannas take note: the tide cannot come in forever. –IT’S ALL GOOD, July 16, 2007
Highlight(yellow) – Page 68 · Location 1277
“perversity of risk.”
Highlight(blue) – Page 68 · Location 1281
static,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 69 · Location 1287
I’m firmly convinced that investment risk resides most where it is least perceived, and vice versa:
Highlight(yellow) – Page 69 · Location 1288
When everyone believes something is risky, their unwillingness to buy usually reduces its price to the point where it’s not risky at all. Broadly negative opinion can make it the least risky thing, since all optimism has been driven out of its price.
Note – Page 69 · Location 1290
Chinese market. Bank. Coal. Shipping. 4-8-2013
Highlight(blue) – Page 71 · Location 1310
it’s the investor’s job to intelligently bear risk for profit. Doing it well is what separates the best from the rest.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 71 · Location 1312
High absolute return is much more recognizable and titillating than superior risk-adjusted performance. That’s why it’s high-returning investors who get their pictures in the papers.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 71 · Location 1316
the importance of managing risk is widely underappreciated, investors rarely gain recognition for having done a great job in this regard. That’s especially true in good times.
Highlight(pink) – Page 71 · Location 1318
commensurate
Highlight(yellow) – Page 72 · Location 1321
Warren Buffett, Peter Lynch, Bill Miller and Julian Robertson.
Highlight(pink) – Page 72 · Location 1324
covert,
Highlight(pink) – Page 72 · Location 1330
salutary,
Highlight(pink) – Page 72 · Location 1335
Ergo,
Highlight(pink) – Page 72 · Location 1336
divine
Highlight(yellow) – Page 73 · Location 1338
Bottom line: risk control is invisible in good times but still essential, since good times can so easily turn into bad times.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 74 · Location 1350
semantic
Highlight(yellow) – Page 74 · Location 1353
no mean feat.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 75 · Location 1364
subtle,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 75 · Location 1369
Controlling the risk in your portfolio is a very important and worthwhile pursuit. The fruits, however, come only in the form of losses that don’t happen. Such what-if calculations are difficult in placid times.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 76 · Location 1377
it’s the investor’s job to intelligently bear risk for profit. Doing it well is what separates the best from the rest.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 76 · Location 1391
I’ve said for years that risky assets can make for good investments if they’re cheap enough. The essential element is knowing when that’s the case.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 76 · Location 1392
the best test for which is a record of repeated success over a long period of time.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 77 · Location 1394
risk bearing is neither wise nor unwise per se.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 77 · Location 1399
Extreme volatility and loss surface only infrequently. And as time passes without that happening, it appears more and more likely that it’ll never happen—that assumptions regarding risk were too conservative. Thus, it becomes tempting to relax rules and increase leverage. And often this is done just before the risk finally rears its head.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 78 · Location 1416
misnomer;
Highlight(yellow) – Page 78 · Location 1421
girded
Highlight(yellow) – Page 79 · Location 1433
But if in the future we always said, “We can’t do such-and-such, because the outcome could be worse than we’ve ever seen before,” we’d be frozen in inaction.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 79 · Location 1436
I’ve mused in the past about how much one should devote to preparing for the unlikely disaster. Among other things, the events of 2007–2008 prove there’s no easy answer.
Highlight(blue) – Page 79 · Location 1439
vagaries
Highlight(yellow) – Page 79 · Location 1442
Oaktree doesn’t run from risk. We welcome it at the right time, in the right instances, and at the right price.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 80 · Location 1457
Over a full career, most investors’ results will be determined more by how many losers they have, and how bad they are, than by the greatness of their winners. Skillful risk control is the mark of the superior investor.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 81 · Location 1464
everything is cyclical.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 81 · Location 1464
Cycles always prevail eventually. Nothing goes in one direction forever. Trees don’t grow to the sky. Few things go to zero.
Highlight(blue) – Page 81 · Location 1468
tagline
Highlight(yellow) – Page 81 · Location 1469
we never know what lies ahead, but we can prepare for the possibilities and reduce their sting.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 81 · Location 1471
Rule number one: most things will prove to be cyclical. Rule number two: some of the greatest opportunities for gain and loss come when other people forget rule number one.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 82 · Location 1477
when people are involved, the results are variable and cyclical. The main reason for this, I think, is that people are emotional and inconsistent, not steady and clinical.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 82 · Location 1487
exogenous
Highlight(yellow) – Page 84 · Location 1523
real estate in 1989–1992; emerging markets in 1994–1998; Long-Term Capital Management in 1998; the movie exhibition industry in 1999–2000; venture capital funds and telecommunications companies in 2000–2001. In each case, lenders and investors provided too much cheap money and the result was overexpansion and dramatic losses.
Highlight(blue) – Page 85 · Location 1538
wax and wane
Highlight(blue) – Page 85 · Location 1541
reins
Highlight(yellow) – Page 86 · Location 1545
Investors will overvalue companies when they’re doing well and undervalue them when things get difficult.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 86 · Location 1547
“virtuous cycles” or “vicious cycles”—self-feeding
Highlight(yellow) – Page 86 · Location 1552
dangerous premise that “this time it’s different.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 86 · Location 1554
Oh Yeah? ,
Highlight(blue) – Page 86 · Location 1554
compilation
Highlight(yellow) – Page 87 · Location 1561
“this time it’s different.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 87 · Location 1562
They cite the changes in geopolitics, institutions, technology or behavior that have rendered the “old rules” obsolete. They make investment decisions that extrapolate the recent trend. And then it
Highlight(yellow) – Page 87 · Location 1563
turns out that the old rules do still apply, and the cycle resumes. In the end, trees don’t grow to the sky, and few things go to zero. Rather, most phenomena turn out to be cyclical. –YOU CAN’T PREDICT. YOU CAN PREPARE, November 20, 2001
Highlight(yellow) – Page 87 · Location 1569
Ignoring cycles and extrapolating trends is one of the most dangerous things an investor can do. People often act as if companies that are doing well will do well forever,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 87 · Location 1571
and investments that are outperforming will
Highlight(yellow) – Page 87 · Location 1571
outperform forever,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 89 · Location 1583
The second investor memo I ever wrote, back in 1991, was devoted almost entirely to a subject that I have come to think about more and more over the years: the pendulum-like oscillation of investor attitudes and behavior.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 89 · Location 1588
The mood swings of the securities markets resemble the movement of a pendulum. Although the midpoint of its arc best describes the location of the pendulum “on average,” it actually spends very little of its time there. Instead, it is almost always swinging toward or away from the extremes of its arc. But whenever the pendulum is near either extreme, it is inevitable that it will move back toward the midpoint sooner or later. In fact, it is the movement toward an extreme itself that supplies the energy for the swing back.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 90 · Location 1595
investor psychology seems to spend much more time at the extremes than it does at a “happy medium.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 90 · Location 1599
credulousness versus skepticism; and risk tolerance versus risk aversion.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 90 · Location 1605
When greed is prevalent, it means investors feel a high level of comfort with risk and the idea of bearing it in the interest of profit. Conversely, widespread fear indicates a high level of aversion to risk. The academics consider investors’ attitude toward risk a constant, but certainly it fluctuates greatly.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 91 · Location 1618
The pendulum swing regarding attitudes toward risk is one of the most powerful of all.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 91 · Location 1619
the risk of losing money and the risk of missing opportunity.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 91 · Location 1619
It’s possible to largely eliminate either one, but not both.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 92 · Location 1627
scintilla
Highlight(orange) – Page 92 · Location 1635
the three stages of a bull market.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 92 · Location 1636
The first, when a few forward-looking people begin to believe things will get better The second, when most investors realize improvement is actually
Highlight(yellow) – Page 92 · Location 1637
taking place The third, when everyone concludes things will get better forever
Highlight(yellow) – Page 93 · Location 1642
Stocks are cheapest when everything looks grim.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 93 · Location 1644
These few words capture the challenges of successful investing. It is hard for the average investor to commit capital to a new
Highlight(yellow) – Page 93 · Location 1645
investment when the outlook is gloomy. Yet it is precisely in these moments that potential returns are at their highest.
Highlight(blue) – Page 93 · Location 1652
giddiness
Highlight(yellow) – Page 94 · Location 1661
the three stages of a bear market: The first, when just a few thoughtful investors recognize that, despite the prevailing bullishness, things won’t always be rosy The second, when most investors recognize things are deteriorating The third, when everyone’s convinced things can only get worse
Highlight(blue) – Page 94 · Location 1675
nadir,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 95 · Location 1683
pendulum
Highlight(yellow) – Page 95 · Location 1683
rephrase its key observations:
Highlight(yellow) – Page 96 · Location 1695
never know:
Highlight(yellow) – Page 96 · Location 1699
reticence….
Highlight(yellow) – Page 97 · Location 1714
Why do mistakes occur? Because investing is an action undertaken by human beings, most of whom are at the mercy of their psyches and emotions.
Highlight(blue) – Page 98 · Location 1726
inimical
Highlight(yellow) – Page 98 · Location 1730
People who don’t care about money generally don’t go into investing.)
Highlight(blue) – Page 99 · Location 1734
trepidation
Highlight(yellow) – Page 99 · Location 1741
fear like greed—connotes excess.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 99 · Location 1746
“Nothing is easier than self-deceit. For what each man wishes, that he also believes to be true.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 100 · Location 1752
the process of investing requires a strong dose of disbelief. . . . Inadequate skepticism contributes to investment losses.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 100 · Location 1756
“Extreme brevity of the financial memory,” to use John Kenneth Galbraith’s wonderful phrase,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 101 · Location 1776
Greenblatt:
Highlight(yellow) – Page 101 · Location 1781
“Rising prices are a narcotic that affects the reasoning power up and down the line.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 101 · Location 1783
How Markets Fail , John Cassidy
Highlight(yellow) – Page 102 · Location 1800
invidious.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 103 · Location 1811
deleterious
Highlight(yellow) – Page 103 · Location 1814
ego .
Highlight(blue) – Page 104 · Location 1820
lofty
Highlight(yellow) – Page 104 · Location 1821
the road to investment success is usually marked by humility, not ego.
Highlight(blue) – Page 104 · Location 1824
gratification
Highlight(yellow) – Page 104 · Location 1826
capitulation ,
Highlight(blue) – Page 104 · Location 1829
nuances
Highlight(orange) – Page 104 · Location 1830
But then psychology and crowd influences move in. Much of the time, assets are overpriced and appreciating further, or underpriced and still cheapening. Eventually these trends have a corrosive effect on investors’ psyches, conviction and resolve. The stocks you rejected are making money for others, the ones you chose to buy are lower every day, and concepts you dismissed as unsafe or unwise—hot new issues, high-priced
Highlight(orange) – Page 104 · Location 1833
tech stocks without earnings, highly levered mortgage derivatives—are described daily as delivering for others. As an overpriced stock goes even higher or an underpriced stock continues to cheapen, it should get easier to do the right thing: sell the former and buy the latter. But it doesn’t. The tendency toward self-doubt combines with news of other people’s successes to form a powerful force that makes investors do the wrong thing, and it gains additional strength as these trends go on longer. It’s one more influence that must be fought.
Highlight(blue) – Page 105 · Location 1840
rumbles
Highlight(orange) – Page 105 · Location 1841
The desire for more, the fear of missing out, the tendency to compare against others, the influence of the crowd and the dream of the sure thing—these factors are near universal. Thus they have a profound collective impact on most investors and most markets. This is especially true at the market extremes. The result is mistakes—frequent, widespread, recurring, expensive mistakes.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 105 · Location 1854
Standard & Poor’s 500 stock index showed a gain every year from 1991 through 1999 inclusive, and its return averaged 20.8 percent per year.
Highlight(blue) – Page 106 · Location 1873
converts
Highlight(blue) – Page 107 · Location 1875
lauded
Highlight(blue) – Page 107 · Location 1877
astuteness.
Highlight(blue) – Page 107 · Location 1877
modicum
Highlight(blue) – Page 107 · Location 1888
fad
Highlight(blue) – Page 109 · Location 1891
vaunted
Highlight(blue) – Page 109 · Location 1902
grumps,
Highlight(blue) – Page 109 · Location 1903
fogeys
Highlight(blue) – Page 109 · Location 1905
abstain.
Highlight(blue) – Page 109 · Location 1913
laggard
Highlight(blue) – Page 109 · Location 1916
peril.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 109 · Location 1919
Believe me, it’s hard to resist buying at the top (and harder still to sell)
Highlight(blue) – Page 109 · Location 1920
pundits
Highlight(yellow) – Page 110 · Location 1928
“It’s not supposed to be easy.”
Highlight(orange) – Page 110 · Location 1929
Here are the ones that work for Oaktree:
Highlight(orange) – Page 110 · Location 1929
a strongly held sense of intrinsic value,
Highlight(blue) – Page 110 · Location 1934
conversance
Highlight(blue) – Page 110 · Location 1935
insidious
Highlight(orange) – Page 111 · Location 1941
Contrarianism
Highlight(yellow) – Page 111 · Location 1941
To buy when others are despondently selling and to sell when others are euphorically buying takes the greatest courage, but provides the greatest profit.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 111 · Location 1944
trend followers .
Highlight(blue) – Page 112 · Location 1954
stampedes
Highlight(blue) – Page 112 · Location 1955
CREED,
Highlight(blue) – Page 112 · Location 1968
rabid
Highlight(yellow) – Page 113 · Location 1976
buy when they hate ’em, and sell when they love ’em.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 113 · Location 1976
“Once-in-a-lifetime” market extremes seem to occur once every decade or so—not often enough for an investor to build a career around capitalizing on them.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 113 · Location 1985
the six-foot-tall man who drowned crossing the stream that was five feet deep on average.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 113 · Location 1988
In the long run, the market gets it right. But you have to survive over the short run, to get to the long run.
Highlight(blue) – Page 114 · Location 1990
plucking.
Highlight(orange) – Page 114 · Location 1996
Contrarianism isn’t an approach that will make you money all of the time. Much of the time there aren’t great market excesses to bet against.
Highlight(orange) – Page 114 · Location 1999
just because no one else will jump in front of a Mack truck barreling down the highway, doesn’t mean that you should!
Highlight(yellow) – Page 115 · Location 2010
based on reason and analysis. You must do things not just because they’re the opposite of what the crowd is doing, but because you know why the crowd is wrong.
Highlight(orange) – Page 115 · Location 2011
Only then will you be able to hold firmly to your views and perhaps buy more as your positions take on the appearance of mistakes and as losses accrue rather than gains.
Highlight(orange) – Page 115 · Location 2012
David Swensen
Highlight(blue) – Page 115 · Location 2017
whipsaw
Highlight(blue) – Page 115 · Location 2020
unravel.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 116 · Location 2028
Fear of looking wrong : The very words used here—uninstitutional, idiosyncratic, imprudent, lonely, and uncomfortable—provide an idea of how challenging it is to maintain nonconsensus positions. But doing so is an absolute must if superior performance is to be achieved.
Highlight(blue) – Page 117 · Location 2054
iconoclastic
Highlight(blue) – Page 118 · Location 2058
epiphanies,
Highlight(blue) – Page 118 · Location 2059
bemoan
Highlight(yellow) – Page 118 · Location 2060
investment skepticism is associated with rejecting investment
Highlight(blue) – Page 118 · Location 2061
fads,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 118 · Location 2061
bull market
Highlight(blue) – Page 118 · Location 2061
manias
Highlight(yellow) – Page 118 · Location 2061
and Ponzi schemes.
Highlight(blue) – Page 118 · Location 2061
epiphany
Highlight(yellow) – Page 118 · Location 2072
During the crisis, lots of bad things seemed possible, but that didn’t mean they were going to happen. In times of crisis, people fail to make that distinction….
Highlight(yellow) – Page 119 · Location 2084
you’ll be a conformist, not a maverick; a follower, not a contrarian.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 120 · Location 2107
Certain common threads run through the best investments I’ve witnessed. They’re usually contrarian, challenging and uncomfortable—although
Highlight(yellow) – Page 121 · Location 2114
The one thing I’m sure of is that by the time the knife has stopped falling, the dust has settled and the uncertainty has been resolved, there’ll be no great bargains left. When buying something has become comfortable again, its price will no longer be so low that it’s a great bargain.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 121 · Location 2118
Thus, a hugely profitable investment that doesn’t begin with discomfort is usually an oxymoron.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 122 · Location 2130
Even sophisticated investors may not say, “I’ll buy anything if it’s cheap enough.” More often they create a list of investment candidates meeting their minimum criteria, and from those they choose the best bargains.
Highlight(blue) – Page 123 · Location 2134
obsolescence
Highlight(orange) – Page 124 · Location 2153
Sid Cottle,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 124 · Location 2154
“investment is the discipline of relative selection.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 125 · Location 2181
potential bargains usually display some objective defect.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 126 · Location 2184
bargains are often created when investors either fail to consider an asset fairly, or fail to look beneath the surface to understand it thoroughly, or fail to overcome some non-value-based tradition, bias or stricture.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 126 · Location 2186
ignored or scorned.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 126 · Location 2187
Seth Klarman: Generally, the greater the
Highlight(blue) – Page 126 · Location 2188
stigma
Highlight(blue) – Page 126 · Location 2188
revulsion,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 126 · Location 2188
the
Highlight(yellow) – Page 126 · Location 2188
better the bargain.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 126 · Location 2192
highly unpopular.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 126 · Location 2192
no one can think of a reason to own it.
Highlight(blue) – Page 126 · Location 2196
decimated
Highlight(blue) – Page 127 · Location 2206
exogenous
Highlight(orange) – Page 127 · Location 2212
Fairly priced assets are never our objective, since it’s reasonable to conclude they’ll deliver just fair returns for the risk involved. And, of course, overpriced assets don’t do us any good.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 127 · Location 2213
A good place to start is among things that are: little known and not fully understood; fundamentally questionable on the surface; controversial, unseemly or scary; deemed inappropriate for “respectable” portfolios; unappreciated, unpopular and unloved; trailing a record of poor returns; and recently the subject of disinvestment, not accumulation.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 128 · Location 2218
the necessary condition for the existence of bargains is that perception has to be considerably worse than reality.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 128 · Location 2219
That means the best opportunities are usually found among things most others won’t do. After all, if everyone feels good about something and is glad to join in, it won’t be bargain-priced.
Highlight(blue) – Page 128 · Location 2226
garner
Highlight(pink) – Page 128 · Location 2228
“Real men don’t buy converts, so chickens like me can buy cheap.”
Highlight(blue) – Page 128 · Location 2229
sobriquet
Highlight(orange) – Page 129 · Location 2240
if nobody owns something, demand for it (and thus the price) can only go up and (b) by going from taboo to even just tolerated, it can perform quite well.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 129 · Location 2245
given the way investors behave, whatever asset is considered the worst at a given point in time has a good likelihood of being the cheapest.
Highlight(blue) – Page 129 · Location 2247
litmus
Highlight(yellow) – Page 131 · Location 2274
You’ll do better if you wait for investments to come to you rather than go chasing after them. You
Highlight(yellow) – Page 132 · Location 2277
“we don’t look for our investments; they find us.” We try to sit on our hands. We don’t go out with a “buy list”; rather, we wait for the phone to ring.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 133 · Location 2295
mujo means cycles will rise and fall, things will come and go, and our environment will change in ways beyond our control. Thus we must recognize, accept, cope and respond.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 133 · Location 2300
In Berkshire Hathaway’s 1997 Annual Report, Buffett talked about Ted Williams—the “Splendid Splinter”—one of the greatest hitters in history. A factor that contributed to his success was his intensive study of his own game. By breaking down the strike zone into 77 baseball-sized “cells” and charting his results at the plate, he learned that his batting average was much better when he went after only pitches in his “sweet spot.” Of course, even with that knowledge, he couldn’t wait all day for the perfect pitch; if he let three strikes go by without swinging, he’d be called out.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 133 · Location 2307
investors needn’t feel pressured to act. They can pass up lots of opportunities until they see one that’s terrific.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 133 · Location 2308
“Investing is the greatest business in the world because you never have to swing. You stand at the plate; the pitcher throws you General Motors at 47! U.S. Steel at 39! And nobody calls a strike on you. There’s no penalty except opportunity. All day you wait for the pitch you like; then, when the fielders are asleep, you step up and hit it.” –WHAT’S YOUR GAME PLAN?
Highlight(blue) – Page 134 · Location 2316
calibration
Highlight(yellow) – Page 134 · Location 2316
Set the bar too high and you might remain out of the market for a very long time. Set it too low and you will be fully invested almost immediately; it will be as though you had no standards at all. Experience and versatile thinking are the keys to such calibration.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 134 · Location 2323
The key is managing clients effectively—which almost always means lowering client expectations.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 134 · Location 2324
missing a profitable opportunity is of less significance than investing in a loser.
Highlight(blue) – Page 135 · Location 2331
allegory
Highlight(blue) – Page 135 · Location 2336
prods
Highlight(yellow) – Page 136 · Location 2344
investors succumbed to the siren song of leverage. They borrowed cheap short-term funds—the shorter
Highlight(yellow) – Page 136 · Location 2344
the cheaper
Highlight(yellow) – Page 136 · Location 2355
You simply cannot create investment opportunities when they’re not there. The dumbest thing you can do is to insist on perpetuating high returns—and give back your profits in the process. If it’s not there, hoping won’t make it so. When prices are high, it’s inescapable that prospective returns are low (and risks are high).
Highlight(yellow) – Page 137 · Location 2367
Peter Bernstein
Highlight(yellow) – Page 137 · Location 2368
“The market’s not a very accommodating machine; it won’t provide high returns just because you need them.”
Highlight(blue) – Page 138 · Location 2379
droning
Highlight(blue) – Page 138 · Location 2383
paucity
Highlight(blue) – Page 138 · Location 2384
ballyhooed
Highlight(yellow) – Page 138 · Location 2388
You want to take risk when others are fleeing from it, not
Highlight(yellow) – Page 138 · Location 2388
when they’re competing with you to do so.
Highlight(blue) – Page 138 · Location 2390
pitfalls
Highlight(yellow) – Page 139 · Location 2394
Being early provided a good reminder about the pain involved in being too far ahead of your time. Having said that, it was much better to get off too soon in May 2005 than to stay on past May 2007.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 140 · Location 2412
The beauty of forced sellers is that they have no choice.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 140 · Location 2412
Those last three words—regardless of price are the most beautiful in the world if you’re on the other side of the transaction.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 141 · Location 2437
This was a time for the patient opportunist to step forward. It was primarily those who had been cognizant of the risks in 2006 and 2007 and kept their powder dry—waiting for opportunity—who were able to do so. The key during a crisis is to be (a) insulated from the forces that require selling and (b) positioned to be a buyer instead.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 142 · Location 2446
We have two classes of forecasters: Those who don’t know—and those who don’t know they don’t know. –John Kenneth Galbraith It’s frightening to think that you might not know something, but more frightening to think that, by and large, the world is run by people who have faith that they know exactly what’s going on. –Amos Tversky There are two kinds of people who lose money: those who know
Highlight(yellow) – Page 142 · Location 2451
nothing and those who know everything. –Henry Kaufman
Highlight(blue) – Page 143 · Location 2466
undaunted.
Highlight(blue) – Page 144 · Location 2478
gyrations
Highlight(blue) – Page 147 · Location 2532
gratis.
Highlight(blue) – Page 147 · Location 2533
prone
Highlight(yellow) – Page 148 · Location 2538
Its adherents generally believe you can’t know the future; you don’t have to know the future; and the proper goal is to do the best possible job of
Highlight(yellow) – Page 148 · Location 2539
investing in the absence of that knowledge.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 149 · Location 2556
Understanding uncertainty :
Highlight(blue) – Page 150 · Location 2572
nadir. –TOUCHSTONES,
Highlight(blue) – Page 150 · Location 2576
foolhardy
Highlight(yellow) – Page 150 · Location 2578
Maybe Mark Twain put it best: “It ain’t what you don’t know that gets you into trouble. It’s what you know for sure that just ain’t so.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 150 · Location 2580
Acknowledging the boundaries of what you can know—and working within those limits rather than venturing beyond—can give you a great advantage.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 151 · Location 2584
We may never know where we’re going, but we’d better have a good idea where we are.
Highlight(blue) – Page 151 · Location 2585
daunting
Highlight(yellow) – Page 151 · Location 2590
a great deal of data, and all my experience, tell me that the only thing we can predict about cycles is their inevitability.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 151 · Location 2592
The second possibility is to accept that the future isn’t knowable, throw up our hands, and simply ignore cycles. Instead of trying to predict them, we could try to make good investments and hold them throughout.
Highlight(blue) – Page 152 · Location 2603
dogmatic:
Highlight(yellow) – Page 153 · Location 2618
First, we must be alert to what’s going on.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 153 · Location 2620
“take the market’s temperature.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 153 · Location 2626
So look around, and ask yourself: Are investors optimistic or pessimistic ? Do the media talking heads say the markets should be piled into or avoided? Are novel investment schemes readily accepted or dismissed out of hand? Are securities offerings and fund openings being treated as opportunities to get rich or possible pitfalls? Has the credit cycle rendered capital readily available or impossible to obtain? Are price/earnings ratios high or low in the context of history, and are yield spreads tight or generous?
Highlight(yellow) – Page 155 · Location 2654
The seven scariest words in the world for the thoughtful investor—too much money chasing too few deals provided an unusually apt description of market conditions.
Highlight(blue) – Page 155 · Location 2660
torrent
Highlight(yellow) – Page 156 · Location 2674
One trend investors might have observed during this dangerous period, had they been alert, was the movement along the spectrum that runs from skepticism to credulousness in regard to what I described earlier as the silver bullet or can’t-lose investment. Thoughtful investors might have noticed that the appetite for silver bullets was running high, meaning greed had won out over fear and signifying a nonskeptical—and thus risky—market.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 156 · Location 2679
8 to 11 percent
Highlight(yellow) – Page 157 · Location 2680
Too few people recognized that achieving rock-steady returns in that range would be a phenomenal accomplishment—perhaps too good to be true. (N.B.: that’s exactly what Bernard Madoff purported to be earning.)
Highlight(yellow) – Page 157 · Location 2692
there’s simply no magic in investing.
Highlight(blue) – Page 157 · Location 2697
deplane
Highlight(yellow) – Page 158 · Location 2710
Economy: Vibrant Sluggish Outlook: Positive Negative Lenders: Eager Reticent Capital markets: Loose Tight Capital: Plentiful Scarce Terms: Easy Restrictive Interest rates: Low High Spreads: Narrow Wide Investors: Optimistic Pessimistic Sanguine Distressed Eager to buy Uninterested in buying Asset owners: Happy to hold Rushing for the exits Sellers: Few Many Markets: Crowded Starved for attention Funds: Hard to gain entry Open to anyone New ones daily Only the best can raise money
Highlight(yellow) – Page 159 · Location 2717
General Partners hold all the cards Limited Partners have bargaining power Recent performance: Strong Weak Asset prices: High Low Prospective returns: Low High Risk: High Low Popular qualities: Aggressiveness Broad reach Caution and discipline Selectivity
Highlight(blue) – Page 160 · Location 2727
oscillates,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 161 · Location 2734
The investment world is not an orderly and logical place where the future can be predicted and specific actions always produce specific results.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 161 · Location 2735
The truth is, much in investing is ruled by luck. Some may prefer to call it chance or randomness , and those words do sound more sophisticated than luck . But it comes down to the same thing: a great
Highlight(yellow) – Page 161 · Location 2736
deal of the success of everything we do as investors will be heavily influenced by the roll of the dice.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 161 · Location 2738
Paul Johnson:
Highlight(yellow) – Page 161 · Location 2738
For me the theme of this chapter is: Learn to be honest with yourself about your successes and failures. Learn to recognize the role luck has played in all outcomes. Learn to decide which outcomes came about because of skill and which because of luck. Until one learns to identify the true source of success, one will be fooled by randomness.
Highlight(blue) – Page 163 · Location 2761
musty
Highlight(yellow) – Page 163 · Location 2776
Warren Buffett’s appendix to the fourth revised edition of The Intelligent Investor describes a contest in which each of the 225 million Americans starts with $1 and flips a coin once a day. The people who get it right on day one collect a dollar from those who were wrong and go on to flip again on day two, and so forth. Ten days later, 220,000 people have called it right ten times in a row and won $1,000. “They may try to be modest, but at cocktail parties they will occasionally admit to attractive members of the opposite sex what their technique is, and what marvelous insights they bring to the field of flipping.” After another ten days, we’re down to 215 survivors who’ve been right 20 times in a row and have each won $1 million.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 164 · Location 2781
They write books titled like How I Turned a Dollar into a Million in Twenty Days Working Thirty Seconds a Morning and sell tickets to seminars. Sound familiar?
Highlight(yellow) – Page 164 · Location 2793
when things go right, luck looks like skill.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 164 · Location 2800
Taleb’s important points.
Highlight(blue) – Page 165 · Location 2808
coup
Highlight(blue) – Page 165 · Location 2814
subset
Highlight(blue) – Page 166 · Location 2826
folly.
Highlight(blue) – Page 166 · Location 2828
flier.
Highlight(blue) – Page 167 · Location 2836
stoic
Highlight(yellow) – Page 167 · Location 2838
Since the investors of the “I know” school, described in chapter 14, feel it’s possible to know the future, they decide what it will look like, build portfolios designed to maximize returns under that one scenario, and largely disregard the other possibilities. The suboptimizers of the “I don’t know” school, on the other hand, put their emphasis on constructing portfolios that will do well in the scenarios they consider likely and not too poorly in the rest. Investors who belong to the “I know” school predict how the dice will come up, attribute their successes to their astute sense of the future, and blame bad luck when things don’t go their way. When they’re right, the
Highlight(blue) – Page 167 · Location 2850
impostors,
Highlight(blue) – Page 168 · Location 2859
ken
Highlight(yellow) – Page 169 · Location 2875
that school of thought.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 171 · Location 2892
There are old investors, and there are bold investors, but there are no old bold investors.
Highlight(blue) – Page 171 · Location 2896
what ails you.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 172 · Location 2902
Charles Ellis, titled “The Loser’s Game,”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 172 · Location 2902
The Financial Analysts Journal in 1975.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 172 · Location 2915
His views on market efficiency and the high cost of trading led him to conclude that the pursuit of winners in the mainstream stock markets is unlikely to pay off for the investor. Instead, you should try to avoid hitting losers. I found this view of investing absolutely compelling.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 173 · Location 2926
The bottom line is that even highly skilled investors can be guilty of mis-hits, and the overaggressive shot can easily lose them the match. Thus, defense—significant emphasis on keeping things from going wrong—is an important part of every great investor’s game.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 173 · Location 2929
competitive some succeed and some fail, and the distinction is clear.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 173 · Location 2930
quantitative you can see the results in black and white.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 173 · Location 2930
meritocracy in the long term, the better returns go to the superior investors.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 173 · Location 2931
team oriented an effective group can accomplish more than one person.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 173 · Location 2932
satisfying and enjoyable but much more so when you win.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 173 · Location 2933
There can be a premium on aggressiveness, which doesn’t serve well in the long run. Unlucky bounces can be frustrating. Short-term success can lead to widespread recognition without enough
Highlight(yellow) – Page 173 · Location 2935
attention being paid to the likely durability and consistency of the record. Overall, I think investing and sports are quite similar, and so are the decisions they call for.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 174 · Location 2942
I think investing is more like the “football” that’s played outside the United States—soccer. In soccer, the same eleven players are on the field for essentially the whole game. There isn’t an offensive squad and a defensive squad. The same people have to play both ways . . . have to be able to deal with all eventualities. Collectively, those eleven players must have the potential to score goals and stop the opposition from scoring more.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 174 · Location 2947
Because coaches know they won’t have many opportunities to switch between offensive and defensive personnel during the game, they have to come up with a winning lineup and pretty much stick with it.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 175 · Location 2966
And, by the way, there’s no right choice between offense and defense. Lots of possible routes can bring you to success, and your decision should be a function of your personality and leanings, the extent of your belief in your ability, and the peculiarities of the markets you work in and the clients you work for.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 176 · Location 2975
There are two principal elements in investment defense. The first is the exclusion of losers from portfolios. This is best accomplished by conducting extensive due diligence,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 176 · Location 2978
The second element is the avoidance of poor years and, especially, exposure to meltdown in crashes.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 176 · Location 2981
Concentration (the opposite of diversification) and leverage are two examples of offense.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 176 · Location 2982
Use enough of them, however, and they can jeopardize your investment survival
Highlight(blue) – Page 176 · Location 2983
things go awry.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 176 · Location 2990
But is it really that simple? It’s easy to say you should prepare for bad days. But how bad? What’s the worst case, and must you be equipped to meet it every day?
Highlight(yellow) – Page 177 · Location 2995
“Because ensuring the ability to survive under adverse circumstances is incompatible with maximizing returns in the good times, investors must choose between the two.” –THE AVIARY, May 16, 2008
Highlight(blue) – Page 177 · Location 3004
oblige.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 177 · Location 3006
Understanding uncertainty : Despite the presence of uncertainty, many investors try to select the ideal strategy through which to maximize return. But if instead we acknowledge the existence of uncertainty, we should insist on building in a generous margin of safety. That’s what keeps your result tolerable when undesirable outcomes materialize.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 178 · Location 3017
“as long as the music is playing, you’ve got to get up and dance” (Citigroup CEO Charles Prince, Financial Times , July 9, 2007). The pressure to manage a company to increase near-term profits while keeping up with industry peers is one of the greatest problems with today’s business culture.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 178 · Location 3020
The lender who insists on margin for error won’t enjoy the highest highs but will also avoid the lowest lows. That’s what happens to those who emphasize defense.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 179 · Location 3027
Low price is the ultimate source of margin for error.
Highlight(blue) – Page 179 · Location 3029
obsolescence
Highlight(yellow) – Page 179 · Location 3038
largely of whether you’re able to exclude bonds that don’t pay. According to Graham and Dodd, this emphasis on exclusion makes fixed income investing a negative art .
Highlight(blue) – Page 180 · Location 3052
testosterone-laden
Highlight(yellow) – Page 180 · Location 3052
too many people think about how good they are and how much they’ll make if they swing for
Highlight(yellow) – Page 180 · Location 3053
the fences and connect.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 181 · Location 3064
they don’t have enough winners, but because they have too many losers.
Highlight(blue) – Page 181 · Location 3070
escorted
Highlight(yellow) – Page 181 · Location 3071
They bet too much when they think they have a winning idea or a correct view of the future, concentrating their portfolios rather than diversifying. They incur excessive transaction costs by changing their holdings too often or attempting to time the market. And they position their portfolios for favorable scenarios and hoped-for outcomes, rather than ensuring that they’ll be able to survive the inevitable miscalculation or stroke of bad luck.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 181 · Location 3075
“if we avoid the losers, the winners will take care of themselves.”
Highlight(blue) – Page 181 · Location 3076
home runs.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 181 · Location 3076
We know others will get the headlines for their big victories and spectacular seasons. But we expect to be around at the finish because of consistent good performance that produces satisfied clients. –WHAT’S YOUR GAME PLAN? September 5, 2003
Highlight(blue) – Page 182 · Location 3082
high-octane
Highlight(yellow) – Page 182 · Location 3083
the more challenging and potentially lucrative the waters you fish in, the more likely they are to have attracted skilled fishermen. Unless your skills render you fully competitive, you’re more likely to be prey than victor. Playing offense, bearing risk and operating in technically challenging fields mustn’t be attempted without the requisite competence.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 182 · Location 3088
Operating a high-risk portfolio is like performing on the high wire without a net. The payoff for success maybe high and bring oohs and aahs. But those slipups will kill you.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 182 · Location 3094
The cautious seldom err or write great poetry.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 183 · Location 3102
conundrum:
Highlight(yellow) – Page 183 · Location 3106
the fear of looking wrong interferes with implementing judgments and how hard it is to be a successful investor if you’re worried about appearances.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 183 · Location 3108
if you’re dominated by an unwillingness to be wrong, you’ll never be able to adopt the lonely, contrarian positions required for serious investment success.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 183 · Location 3110
In investing, almost everything is a two-edged sword.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 183 · Location 3111
The only exception is genuine personal skill.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 183 · Location 3111
if it’ll help if it works, that means it’ll hurt if it doesn’t.
Highlight(blue) – Page 183 · Location 3114
unmet.
Highlight(blue) – Page 184 · Location 3118
erudite,
Highlight(orange) – Page 184 · Location 3118
Invest scared!
Highlight(yellow) – Page 184 · Location 3122
Worry about the possibility of loss. Worry that there’s something you don’t know. Worry that you can make high-quality decisions but still be hit by bad luck or surprise events. Investing scared will prevent hubris; will keep your guard up and your mental adrenaline flowing; will make you insist on adequate margin of safety; and will increase the chances that your portfolio is prepared for things going wrong. And if nothing does go wrong, surely the winners will take care of themselves. –THE MOST IMPORTANT THING, July 1, 2003
Highlight(yellow) – Page 185 · Location 3129
An investor needs do very few things right as long as he avoids big mistakes. –Warren Buffett
Highlight(yellow) – Page 186 · Location 3153
“Failure of imagination”—the inability to understand in advance the full breadth of the range of outcomes—is
Highlight(blue) – Page 187 · Location 3162
extrapolation
Highlight(yellow) – Page 187 · Location 3163
Bruce Newberg’s
Highlight(blue) – Page 187 · Location 3163
pithy
Highlight(yellow) – Page 187 · Location 3164
Things that aren’t supposed to happen do happen.
Highlight(blue) – Page 187 · Location 3165
cluster.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 187 · Location 3165
double sixes should come up once in every 36 rolls of the dice. But they can come up five times in a row—and never again in the next 175 rolls—and in the long run have occurred as often as they’re supposed to.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 187 · Location 3166
Relying to excess on the fact that something “should happen” can kill you when it doesn’t. Even if you properly understand the underlying probability distribution, you can’t count on things happening as they’re supposed to. And the success of your investment actions shouldn’t be highly dependent on normal outcomes prevailing; instead, you must allow for outliers.
Highlight(blue) – Page 187 · Location 3170
unequivocal
Highlight(yellow) – Page 188 · Location 3176
Most of the meltdowns in the recent credit crisis took place because something didn’t go as it was supposed to.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 188 · Location 3176
The financial crisis occurred largely because never-before-seen events collided with risky, levered structures that weren’t engineered to withstand them.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 188 · Location 3182
As an aside, it’s worth noting that the assumption that something can’t happen has the potential to make it happen, since people who believe it can’t happen will engage in risky behavior and thus alter the environment.
Highlight(blue) – Page 188 · Location 3184
inextricably
Highlight(yellow) – Page 188 · Location 3185
mortgage payments were limited to 25 percent of monthly income by tradition;
Highlight(yellow) – Page 189 · Location 3207
In many ways, psychological forces are some of the most interesting sources of investment terror. They can greatly influence security prices. When they cause some investors to take an extreme view that isn’t balanced out by others, these forces can make prices go way too high or way too low. This is the origin of bubbles and crashes.
Highlight(blue) – Page 192 · Location 3247
devastated
Highlight(blue) – Page 192 · Location 3252
stringency,
Highlight(blue) – Page 192 · Location 3254
slender
Highlight(yellow) – Page 193 · Location 3265
The best defense against loss is thorough, insightful analysis and insistence on what Warren Buffett calls “margin for error.”
Highlight(blue) – Page 193 · Location 3267
fogeys.
Highlight(blue) – Page 193 · Location 3267
heady
Highlight(blue) – Page 194 · Location 3282
aberrant
Highlight(yellow) – Page 194 · Location 3284
as Buffett has said, “Beware of geeks with models.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 194 · Location 3287
It makes little sense to use leverage to try to turn inadequate returns into adequate returns.
Highlight(blue) – Page 194 · Location 3290
nugget.
Highlight(blue) – Page 195 · Location 3299
pernicious
Highlight(blue) – Page 195 · Location 3302
enumerated
Highlight(yellow) – Page 195 · Location 3302
Pitfalls were everywhere: investors were unworried, even ebullient in the years leading up. People believed that risk had been banished, and thus they need worry only about missing opportunity and failing to keep up, not about losing money.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 195 · Location 3307
The riskiest things : A high level of belief and a corresponding low level of skepticism always play a large part in the ascent of prices that, afterward, everyone sees as having risen too high.
Highlight(blue) – Page 197 · Location 3335
equanimity
Highlight(blue) – Page 197 · Location 3336
carnage
Highlight(yellow) – Page 197 · Location 3339
Surviving the declines and buying at the resultant lows was a great formula for success—especially relative success—but first it required the avoidance of pitfalls.
Highlight(blue) – Page 198 · Location 3345
furtherance.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 198 · Location 3356
to think about what “today’s mistake” might be and try to avoid it.
Highlight(blue) – Page 201 · Location 3378
asymmetrical.
Highlight(blue) – Page 201 · Location 3379
propitious
Highlight(blue) – Page 202 · Location 3389
epitomizes
Highlight(blue) – Page 202 · Location 3390
emulating
Highlight(yellow) – Page 202 · Location 3403
Active investors who don’t possess the superior insight described in chapter 1 are no better than passive investors,
Highlight(yellow) – Page 202 · Location 3405
their risk-adjusted performance shouldn’t be expected to be better than the passive portfolio.
Highlight(blue) – Page 203 · Location 3409
peculiarities.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 205 · Location 3461
This one has a ton, if you can live with the volatility:
Highlight(yellow) – Page 206 · Location 3472
A single year says almost nothing about skill, especially when the
Highlight(yellow) – Page 206 · Location 3473
results are in line with what would be expected on the basis of the investor’s style.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 206 · Location 3474
The real question is how they do in the long run and in climates for which their style is ill suited.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 206 · Location 3478
With Skill Gains a lot when the market goes up, but doesn’t lose to the same degree when the market goes down Doesn’t lose much when the market goes down, but captures a fair bit of the gain when the market goes up
Highlight(yellow) – Page 206 · Location 3482
Without skill, aggressive investors move a lot in both directions, and defensive investors move little in either direction.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 207 · Location 3487
Everything in investing is a two-edged sword and operates symmetrically, with the exception of superior skill.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 207 · Location 3487
Only skill can be counted on to add more in propitious environments than it costs in hostile ones. This is the investment asymmetry we seek. Superior skill is the prerequisite for it.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 207 · Location 3493
in the good years average is good enough.
Highlight(blue) – Page 207 · Location 3495
brunt
Highlight(yellow) – Page 207 · Location 3495
it’s our goal to do as well as the market when it does well and better than the market when it does poorly. At first blush that may sound like a modest goal, but it’s really quite ambitious.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 208 · Location 3503
Oaktree actually returns capital whenever the opportunity set shrinks.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 208 · Location 3505
Asymmetry—better performance on the upside than on the downside relative to what your style alone would produce—should be every investor’s goal.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 209 · Location 3510
no investment activity is likely to be successful unless the return goal is (a) explicit and (b) reasonable in the absolute and relative to the risk entailed.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 209 · Location 3511
Every investment effort should begin with a statement of what you’re trying to accomplish. The key questions are what your return goal is, how much risk you can tolerate, and how much liquidity you’re likely to require in the interim.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 209 · Location 3513
Most of the time—although not necessarily at any particular point in time (and not necessarily today)—it’s reasonable to aspire to returns in single digits or perhaps low double digits. High teens are something very special, and anything more should be viewed as the province of experienced pros (and only the best of those). The same is true of particularly consistent results.
Highlight(blue) – Page 210 · Location 3525
ephemeral
Highlight(blue) – Page 210 · Location 3527
perpetrated
Highlight(yellow) – Page 210 · Location 3529
The returns Madoff claimed weren’t outrageously high: just 10 percent a year or so.
Highlight(pink) – Page 210 · Location 3529
What was extraordinary was the way he reported them year in and year out. Even a down month was a rarity. Yet few of his investors asked how these returns were achieved or wondered whether they were actually possible.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 210 · Location 3531
For most of the twentieth century, common stocks averaged a 10 percent return. But they did it with substantial volatility and a fair number of down years.
Highlight(pink) – Page 211 · Location 3536
He reported those returns for almost twenty years, regardless of the investment environment
Highlight(blue) – Page 211 · Location 3539
avowed
Highlight(yellow) – Page 212 · Location 3556
It’s essential to understand that “cheap” is far from synonymous with “not going to fall further.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 212 · Location 3561
fact alone often causes others to hide behind the excuse that “it’s not our job to catch falling knives.” After all, it’s when knives are falling that the greatest bargains are available.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 212 · Location 3565
Perfection in investing is generally unobtainable; the best we can hope for is to make a lot of good investments and exclude most of the bad ones.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 212 · Location 3567
Rather, if we think something is cheap, we buy. If it gets cheaper, we buy more. And if we commit all our capital, we assume we’ll be able to raise more.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 213 · Location 3570
if we find something attractive, we never say, “It’s cheap today, but we think it’ll be cheaper in six months, so we’ll wait.” It’s just not realistic to expect to be able to buy at the bottom.
Highlight(blue) – Page 213 · Location 3577
monologue.
Highlight(blue) – Page 214 · Location 3588
ostensibly
Highlight(blue) – Page 215 · Location 3595
snippets
Highlight(yellow) – Page 215 · Location 3597
To achieve superior investment results, your insight into value has to be superior. Thus you must learn things others don’t, see things differently or do a better job of analyzing them—ideally, all three.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 216 · Location 3604
The relationship between price and value holds the ultimate key to investment success. Buying below value is the most dependable route to profit. Paying above value rarely works out as well.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 216 · Location 3606
perception understates reality.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 216 · Location 3608
goal is to find good buys, not good assets.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 218 · Location 3628
“What the wise man does in the beginning, the fool does in the end.”
Highlight(blue) – Page 218 · Location 3635
tread more carefully.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 218 · Location 3638
“Being too far ahead of your time is indistinguishable from being wrong.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 219 · Location 3648
Most investors think diversification consists of holding many different things; few understand that diversification is effective only if portfolio holdings can be counted on to respond differently to a given development in the environment.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 219 · Location 3652
“If we avoid the losers, the winners will take care of themselves,”
Highlight(blue) – Page 220 · Location 3659
eschewing
Highlight(yellow) – Page 220 · Location 3661
“Never forget the six-foot-tall man who drowned crossing the stream that was five feet deep on average.”
Highlight(yellow) – Page 220 · Location 3669
The more micro your focus, the greater the likelihood you can learn things others don’t.
Highlight(blue) – Page 221 · Location 3676
kudos
Highlight(yellow) – Page 221 · Location 3677
it’s worth noting that there’s usually someone who gets it exactly right . . . but it’s rarely the same person twice. The most successful investors get things “about right” most of the time, and that’s much better than the rest.
Highlight(blue) – Page 221 · Location 3680
gullibility.
Highlight(yellow) – Page 222 · Location 3685
For us to conclude that investors truly add value, we have to see how they perform in environments to which their style isn’t particularly well suited.
Highlight(blue) – Page 222 · Location 3691
divine
Highlight(blue) – Page 222 · Location 3692
lurk
Highlight(blue) – Page 223 · Location 3702
contextualizing